The Frosty Riff: Ina Garten's Frozen Key Lime Pie Overall rating ... refreshing nature of the filling. But the slices do melt fairly quickly and can get quite messy. (The Kitchn's studio had ...

A slice capped with a lofty cloud of meringue, or a frozen key lime wedge dipped in chocolate and served on a stick are also available at the same single-serving price (slightly more per pie).