The sole basis for Snape's loyalty, based on what Snape actually revealed to Dumbledore, was his commitment to protect Harry on Lily's behalf. Why does Dumbledore suddenly cast doubt on Snape's commitment to honouring Lily and protecting Harry here? Surely that was the basis for his allegiance to the Order all along?

2020年5月8日 · People say the "always" line is obsessive. Nope. If Dumbles had to ask "after all this time", then clearly Snape very much shut up about Lily even when speaking to him. People say it's obsessive that he stole the letter and the picture. Having one lousy souvenir of a dead loved one isn't obsessive.

Even after all the things that had happened, he could still call on his memories of her as the source of the sort of pure feelings and emotion needed to perform the charm. After she left him for his childhood bully, after he lashed out against her for being muggle born, after falling in with Voldemort himself, after all that time...

Disney+ is assembling a live-action series centred around a fan-favorite character from the Marvel Cinematic Universe. "Loki is brought to the mysterious Time Variance Authority organization after stealing the Tesseract during the events of Avengers: Endgame (2019), and travels through time altering human history using it, ending up trapped in his own crime thriller."

2016年12月17日 · After all this time? Always. This thread is archived New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast comments Best samyouare • 7 yr. ago

2022年3月11日 · What's funny is that that quote is nothing to do with love. ‘Have you have grown to CARE for the boy, after all?’ 'for him? Expecto Patronum' After all this time, Snape still cares for Lily, always will care about her. To me, always has nothing to do with love. Sure you can argue that the Patronus shows its love. Probably.

2022年7月30日 · I read the books almost 2 years ago, for the first time in nearly 10 years. I don't particularly recall him using the word "always", but then again books are harder to remember with specificity than films (at least for me) so I concede I may have read him saying that but simply don't remember it, even though it was fairly recent.

2023年6月17日 · After all this time? Always. Dumbledore is surprised that Snape his motivation is still Lily. That he’s still doing this for her even after all this time. He knew he changed sides for her, he’s just surprised she is the reason he’s still risking his life to that day.

2020年7月31日 · The significance of ‘always’ was Snapes love for Lily. One of the main reasons why Snape stayed loyal to Dumbledore was Lily. When he produced the doe patronus, dumbledore asked ‘lily? after all this time’ and snape said ‘always’ this was showing after 17 years he still had the same amount of love for lily as he always had. 2 ...

2023年7月30日 · Well in the movies the Always scene happens at the end of Deathly Hallows, so did you think in the books it would happen one book earlier? Yes I have only read up to the end of half blood prince.